The Real McCoys: Cloth Diapers 4 Months Later

We are 4 months into cloth diapering, so I thought I would do an update post on how they're working, how we like them and the issues we have.

First of all, I did extensive research before deciding what type of system would work for us, so here is our system and why we chose it.

Newborn: For the newborn stage we used Thirsties Size 1 duo wrap covers and Thirsties Size 1 hemp prefolds: we had 6 covers and 25 prefolds, but probably could have gotten by with 4 covers.

We chose to get a system that worked for newborn stage because we plan on cloth diapering multiple kids, and thought we would get our money's worth. I also wanted to start using the diapers as soon as possible.
With that being said, Kate was 8 lbs, 14 oz at birth and was on the smallest setting of the diaper, so this system might not work for all babies.
What we liked:

I really liked this system overall, especially for the first few weeks/month when you are changing so many diapers and they are all of the #2 variety - it was easier to just have a prefold that needed to be washed instead of a whole diaper.
The double gussets are awesome
The hemp prefolds were very soft and very absorbent, they also stayed folded nicely, so we could have them tri-folded and ready to place in a cover as needed.
It was nice to be able to fold down the prefold when changing her diaper, and therefore blocking the mess from her legs while wiping.
We had no problem with her umbilical cord stump hitting the edge of the diaper
Thirsties is a 100% USA company
Economical and Versatile: getting away with less covers(you can reuse them each change as long as they didn't get messy) saves you $, and its also nice to have a choice of what to use in the covers - different types of prefolds or natural fiber inserts. If I were doing it all again I would consider using this type of system permanently.

What could be better:

Fit: this is totally dependent on the baby, but Kate is very long and needs a high rise. She grew out of the size one covers before the weight limit stated, up to 18lbs(she's currently 15.5 lbs and they haven't fit her for about a month) I really only know this because I have the BumGenius to compare to, but the rise is definitely lower on these diapers. That being said, they do have a size 2 that we have not tried, she may have been able to transition just fine if we were continuing that system.
Colors/Prints: Again, this is totally my opinion, but I liked the color and print options of the BumGenius better - definitely getting picky here.
Bulk: the prefolds are bulky, especially on a newborn. The Thirsties hemp ones are slimmer than other types too.

Overall, this system worked great for what we used it for, and we will definitely be using it again in future kiddos. I am also contemplating buying a Size 2 DuoWrap cover just to have as back up.

Main System: For later and beyond we are using BumGenius 4.0 Pocket Diapers

In her first BumGenius Diaper (3.5 weeks)

Why we chose BumGenius: They continuously had good reviews, in all the research I did there were many people that loved their diapers, with just as many that had issues with those same diapers. Because we wanted to register for our diapers, I really wanted to find one brand and type of diaper that would work for us and would last for multiple kids, BumGenius won out because almost everyone who had them loved them, I didn't really find anyone that had major issues with them and they seemed to work fit-wise for most babies. We went with the pocket diapers because of the versatility (stuffing with different inserts and adding boosters), as well as the durability. I really liked that we could dry the inserts in the dryer and hang dry the covers to cut down on the wear and tear on the PUL, but also not have to wait forever for diapers to dry. We chose to go with snaps for durability as well.

What we like:

The fit: Obviously I do not have experience with any other babies, or even other brands of diapers other than the Thirsties covers, but I love the way these diapers fit. They cover what need to be covered, are tight where they need to be tight and just feel secure. Kate is long and has super chunky thighs, so maybe they are just perfect for her body type. We have never had a blow out, and maybe have had 2 or 3 leakage type situations. Each time we have had any issue with a leak it was because she was in her diaper too long, or daddy snapped it too loose.
The style: I love the colors and prints .. there are new ones that I'm itching to buy.
The stretchy tabs: These are apparently a BumGenius exclusive and they are awesome. Kate is slightly between (snap) sizes right now and the stretchy tabs allow us to still get a snug fit without squeezing her little belly too tight. I also like that there are two snaps.
The Convenience: I understand that some people don't like pocket diapers because of the work, but I honestly don't mind stuffing diapers, it takes less time than folding a load of laundry. We love that they are ready to go when its time to put them on, they are just as easy and convenient as disposables.

What could be better:

Natural fibers: I would have preferred a diaper with all natural fiber, although I realize that the suede cloth and microfiber are there to keep the baby dry and for quick absorbency, I would just prefer natural and organic. That being said, I consciously made a choice to go with a non-natural fiber diaper(they are available), so I can't really complain.
The stink: We have very hard water, and with that, we have been battling microfiber stink off and on. I don't like it, but it is not bad enough that I regret the choice of diaper we made, or to cloth diaper in general. We do need to strip about every 6 weeks though.

What we changed:

To appease my wish for natural fibers, and to battle stink issues, we purchased 12 hemp/cotton blend inserts from Geffen Baby. I love them! Hemp is extremely absorbent and trim. We use them as doublers for nighttime, and in place of the microfiber inserts.
I have found what works best is to use the microfiber newborn insert from BumGenius with a Geffen Baby hemp insert - extremely trim (more so than just a full size microfiber), and combines the quick absorbing of the microfiber with the capacity of the hemp insert. So far it has helped with stink, just to have more inserts in the rotation, as well as the hemp being natural fiber and stink resistant. I would love to and probably will buy more hemp inserts to replace the microfiber over time.
We also changed our wash routine from using Charlie's Soap to Rockin Green Hard Rock with their FunkRock Booster. We've heard great things about Charlie's soap, but it just wasn't working for us.

Our System and Routine:

We currently have 30 BumGenius 4.0 Pocket Diapers as well as 12 hemp inserts in rotation.
We use Thirsties Fab cloth wipes and love them - I think we have 40-50 but could make do with less. We just wet them with water and keep about 8-10 in a LionHeart Wipe holder.
We have two Large hanging PlanetWise Wet bags, two pail liners and three medium PlanetWise wet bags. We essentially do not use the pail liners unless we are traveling and could get by with 1. I love the hanging wet bags, and having at least three wet bags for the diaper bag is essential! We also have a PlanetWise wipe holder wet bag, which we keep in the diaper bag.
We use CJs Butter (in lavender) for any red tushes. - Works great!
I wash a load of diapers every night, but we can go a whole weekend (2.5 days) without doing diaper laundry (which we do if we travel)
Daytime: Kate wears the diapers with either just a microfiber insert or the hemp+newborn microfiber combo. I don't really distinguish them, but I do lean towards the hemp combo if she's going to be in the diaper awhile (we're out and about) or she's going to be in her carseat for a long trip - the hemp holds more!
Nighttime: We no longer change her diaper in the middle of the night, so although she isn't sleeping through the night, she still needs an overnight diaper. We are currently stuffing a pocket with the large microfiber insert and 2 hemp inserts - it is bulky but it works. She is on the largest size setting in this get-up so we might need another solution at some point. I will most likely buy a fitted diaper and cover for nighttime down the road. For now, we have had no leaking or other issues with the three inserts + pocket situation.
When we change her diaper we just throw the entire thing, wipes and all in a wet bag - very convenient and quick. I un-stuff them as I am throwing them into the wash - this way my hands only get dirty once (and not when I'm holding the baby) and I would have to pull them out of the bag anyway! We plan on hooking up our diaper sprayer down in the basement and sticking with the same system (spray dirty diapers right before doing wash). We will have to see how this works, but I think it will be ok because I do laundry every day. It might not work if dirty diapers were sitting too long.
Traveling: So far Kate has never had a disposable diaper on after the first two weeks of her life. We have managed to travel home for the weekend and to various relatives with cloth. It takes some planning and is more to pack, but it has not been too much of an inconvenience, at least not enough to make me feel the need to use disposables. If we are home, we do laundry at my parents, if we are somewhere else, we just keep the diapers in one of the large pail liners and do laundry when we get home. We can make it 2.5 days without doing a load (and still have her wearing diapers!) .. This is the situation where I would love to have a back up Thirsties duo cover so that we could use prefolds in a pinch and last one more day without laundry. Maybe I will get one when we need to buy the fitted diaper for overnight.

Probably not the most exciting post, but overall, we are extremely happy with our "system" (all that research worked!) and wouldn't really change anything now. I am even more thankful that we spend next to nothing on diapering this child (all of our diapers were given as gifts), and they are gentle on her skin (which is sensitive). Many of you have heard me say it, but I wish I could convince everyone how easy this is, Kevin agrees. It's definitely worth it for us, plus, they are just so darn cute